
Manuscript critiques, priced by length
Critique rates
First ten pages
Length: a 2-page letterPrice: from $75A close read of your opening ten pages and a letter on what is working and what is not.
Opening chapter
Length: a 3-page critiquePrice: from $140A written critique of your first chapter, covering voice, pacing and the promise it makes.
Short story or essay
Length: a 3-page critiquePrice: from $180A written critique of a piece up to 5,000 words, with notes in the margins.
Query letter and synopsis
Length: about 1 weekPrice: from $120A line edit of both documents with notes on what an agent will see first.
Talk it through
Length: 45 minPrice: from $85A call to go over your pages, your questions and the next draft, with no written report.
Full manuscript
Length: 10-page letter, 3 weeksPrice: from $950A read of the whole book up to 80,000 words and a long editorial letter.
Two sheets and a mug
The checklist and worksheet I hand to writers before they send me anything.
How a critique works
3 steps
- Step 1 of 3
Pick a rate, tell me what you're sending and when you'd like it back. I reply within two working days with a date and where to send the file.
- Step 2 of 3
Once straight through, the way a reader would. Then again with the blue pencil, marking the margins as I go.
- Step 3 of 3
A plain letter on what is working and what is not, as long as the rate says. Your marked pages come back with it.
Latest posts
What I look for on page one
Four things I check before I read to the bottom of the page.
Why I price critiques by length
A plain explanation of the rate card and what each rate covers.
The revision pass nobody does
Reading your own draft out loud, one chapter at a time.
Newsletter
The weekly note
A short note each week about what I find on other people's pages.

About me
I spent fifteen years as a copy chief at a regional publisher. Now I edit novels, memoirs and long essays on my own, and read other people's first chapters for a living.
The note is what I find on those pages, written down once a week. Critiques are priced by how much I read; the checklist and worksheets are downloads you keep, and the blue pencil mug is printed to order and shipped to you.
— Abdirahman Warsame

